Consumers Credit Union cuts revision rate to 7.9% with CVUE

By reducing manual appraisal reviews, Consumers improved turn times, expanded underwriting capacity and scaled for growth.

About

Consumers Credit Union is a member-owned financial cooperative headquartered in Kalamazoo, Michigan. Founded in 1951, it is one of Michigan’s largest credit unions, offering a full range of financial products including checking and savings accounts, auto loans, personal loans, and mortgage services.

The Challenge

With membership growing at a historic pace and plans to expand into new markets, Consumers needed its mortgage operation to keep up.

As the team scaled, collateral valuation emerged as a pressure point. A dedicated appraisal desk managed orders, tracked revisions, and coordinated communication to move reports through the review process. It worked, but it wasn’t built to scale.

The Solution

As Consumers evaluated appraisal management companies, Class Valuation stood out because of CVUE, its Underwriting and Appraisal Assurance Program. CVUE combines advanced AI, computer vision, and expert human review to identify qualifying appraisals that can move forward without a traditional lender-side review. It also assumes repurchase liability that would otherwise remain with the lender, reducing manual review work while maintaining confidence in appraisal quality.

Consumers selected Class Valuation as its AMC, seeing a clear opportunity to increase capacity, reduce manual review work, and maintain appraisal quality through CVUE.

The Results

1.5 days reduction in turn time

Consumers reduced overall loan cycle time by more than one-and-a-half days within approximately six months, a result Summerfield attributes to CVUE, workflow improvements, and the quality of appraisals delivered through Class Valuation.

20 additional files per month

Each underwriter gained enough capacity to handle one additional file per day, creating room for more than 20 additional files per month per underwriter without adding headcount.

7.9% revision rate

With CVUE handling the review on eligible appraisals, Consumers' revision rate dropped to 7.9%, significantly below the industry average of 1 in 4 appraisals.

“When the underwriters get that CVUE certificate, they get very excited. It’s been a big process improvement and morale builder.”
Josh Summerfield
Vice President of Mortgage, Consumers Credit Union

About Class Valuation

Founded in 2009, Class Valuation is a leading nationwide AMC recognized for fast turn times, exceptional quality, and client service. The company combines skilled professionals, innovative products, and advanced technology to help lenders improve efficiency and manage valuation risk. Visit classvaluation.com.

Let's Build Your CVUE Plan